The UK government's tax authority, HMRC, is seeking to expand its powers to demand private chatbot conversations from ordinary Britons when preparing their tax returns. Under proposals in the Budget Bill, the definition of what HMRC can force individuals to hand over would expand from computer "records" to any "relevant thing," potentially including prompt histories, working papers, and full conversations on platforms such as ChatGPT and Microsoft Copilot.
This move is part of a broader effort to close a £59 billion tax gap, with failure to respond to a Schedule 36 information notice already carrying significant penalties. Critics view this expansion of power as a significant overreach, with some arguing that it represents a form of state surveillance.
The Telegraph reports that third parties, including AI companies themselves, can even be ordered to supply the data. However, experts such as Nimesh Shah of Blick Rothenberg and Seb Maley of Qdos note that the language used by HMRC raises questions about the potential for chatbot exchanges to become disclosable.
The idea has been met with strong criticism, with Anne Strickland of the Taxpayers' Alliance calling it "a deeply intrusive overreach by the taxman." She argues that HMRC already has sweeping powers and that expanding them further risks trampling over the privacy of ordinary Britons.
