MURRAY REPORT✉ Free Email News Alerts← us desk
NEWS   /   U.S. NEWS

Malcolm in the Middle of Gun Debate

Photograph accompanying Malcolm in the Middle of Gun Debate (source: Washington Free Beacon)
Washington Free Beacon — publisher photograph (see original for photographer credit)

Malcolm Gladwell has written a new book, The American Way of Killing, which tackles America's problem with gun violence. The book is a mix of gripping storytelling and interesting facts, but at times feels like Gladwell is randomly selecting topics and positions to take on them.

He criticizes both the left and the right for having "dishonest conversations" about gun violence, and attempts to set the record straight. Gladwell's chapter on assault weapons argues that the left has misled the public about the nature of these guns, which do not spray bullets like machine guns.

He notes that assault weapons differ from other semiautomatic rifles mainly in their cosmetic features, and that handguns are more common in everyday gun violence. However, these points may feel obvious to those familiar with the gun-control debate, and some may not find Gladwell's arguments convincing.

The book also discusses the Supreme Court's interpretation of the Second Amendment, with Gladwell arguing that the Court gave short shrift to the amendment's prefatory clause. He suggests that the Founders' concerns about militias were motivated by a desire to protect the South from slave revolts, but this claim has been disputed by other scholars.

The historian Noah Shusterman has highlighted the importance of debates over militias and standing armies at the time, and argues that the Second Amendment was intended to address these concerns. Overall, the book is a thought-provoking contribution to the gun debate, but its arguments may not always be convincing.