MURRAY REPORT✉ Free Email News Alerts← us desk
NEWS   /   U.S. NEWS

Richard A. Posner, Renegade Scholar, Good Friend

Photograph accompanying Richard A. Posner, Renegade Scholar, Good Friend (source: Washington Free Beacon)
Washington Free Beacon — publisher photograph (see original for photographer credit)

The Washington Free Beacon has published a tribute to Richard A. Posner, a renowned scholar who passed away last week at the age of 87. The author of the tribute, a colleague and friend of Posner's, reflects on his early years and his views on antitrust and tort law.

Posner's article "Natural Monopoly and Its Regulation," published in 1968, is cited as an example of his confident and revisionist approach to established scholars. The author also recounts Posner's critical review of Guido Calabresi's book "The Costs of Accidents," which sparked a debate about the law of torts.

The author describes Posner as a master pugilist who was not afraid to challenge established thinkers, but also as a gracious and supportive colleague. A notable example of this is the confrontation between Posner and Ronald Coase, the editor of the Journal of Law and Economics, which led to Posner starting his own journal, the Journal of Legal Studies.

The author also shares a personal anecdote about a dinner at Posner's house, where they engaged in a heated debate about Posner's article "A Theory of Negligence," which was later published in 1972. The author's exchange with Posner at the dinner captured the essence of the man, who was both a fierce debater and a kind and supportive colleague.

Posner's offer to publish the author's views in his new journal helped launch the author's career, and their debate continued in the pages of the Journal of Legal Studies.