MURRAYREPORT: A newly released study examining more than two decades of school shootings across the United States has reported a striking finding: researchers identified no shooting attacks resulting in deaths or injuries during or near classroom hours at schools that allowed authorized teachers and other nonuniformed employees to carry firearms.
The research, conducted by John R. Lott Jr. and the Crime Prevention Research Center (CPRC), reviewed incidents occurring between 2000 and 2025.
According to the findings, schools permitting armed staff recorded no qualifying mass shootings or attacks producing shooting casualties during the period examined.
The results have renewed a longstanding national debate over whether allowing trained school employees to carry concealed firearms could help protect students against violent attacks.
Crime Prevention Research Center+1
Study Compares Schools With Armed Teachers, Security Officers and Gun Restrictions
Researchers examined school shooting and lockdown reports from multiple databases, identifying 1,057 incidents involving gunfire on school property.
The analysis included accidental discharges, suicides, gang-related shootings and deliberate attacks.
Investigators then categorized schools according to their firearm security policies.
The three categories included schools allowing authorized teachers or staff to carry firearms, schools employing armed police or security guards, and schools without an authorized armed presence.
According to the study, the findings revealed substantial differences among those categories.
REPORTED ATTACKS WITH CASUALTIES, 2000–2025
0150300450600Authorized armed staffPolice / security guardsNo authorized armed presence
Source: Crime Prevention Research Center. These are reported counts, not population-adjusted rates; they do not establish causation.
The study found 39 attacks resulting in casualties at schools protected by police officers or paid security guards.
By comparison, researchers identified 551 incidents involving casualties at schools where firearms were not knowingly permitted.
No qualifying attacks resulting in shooting casualties were identified in the category allowing authorized nonuniformed staff to carry guns.
Those figures describe the incidents identified under the researchers' definitions. They do not independently establish that armed-teacher policies caused the differences, because schools can vary in size, location, security arrangements and other risk factors.
Crime Prevention Research Center+1
Researchers Report No Students Harmed by Firearms Taken From Armed Teachers
Another notable finding involved concerns about students gaining access to firearms carried by teachers or other school employees.
Lott reported that researchers could not identify a case in which a student obtained an authorized teacher's or staff member's firearm and used it to injure another person.
The study also found no qualifying case of an authorized armed teacher deliberately or accidentally shooting another person during the period examined.
Researchers did identify an incident in 2014 in which a teacher's firearm discharged inside a school bathroom.
The teacher was injured by fragments from a damaged porcelain toilet, rather than by a gunshot.
The report also identified a student suicide in 2001 involving a firearm brought to school by the student.
These incidents illustrate the importance of distinguishing between shooting attacks, accidental firearm discharges and other firearm-related injuries.
Crime Prevention Research Center+1
School Resource Officers Involved in Multiple Accidental Gun Discharges
The report also examined firearm-related incidents involving law enforcement personnel and private security guards assigned to schools.
According to Lott's analysis, researchers identified 20 accidental firearm discharges involving police officers and six involving private security guards.
Two additional incidents involved security officers' firearms discharging during physical struggles.
Researchers also reported three incidents in which police officers struck unintended individuals or may have mistaken bystanders for threats.
One documented incident involved a student obtaining a school resource officer's handgun and accidentally discharging it.
These findings have contributed to questions about the different risks and responsibilities associated with armed school security personnel and authorized concealed-carry employees.
Crime Prevention Research Center+1
Armed Teachers Debate Intensified After Columbine and Sandy Hook
The issue of arming educators has remained controversial for decades.
Following the 1999 Columbine High School massacre in Colorado and the 2012 Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting in Connecticut, lawmakers and school officials explored additional measures to protect students.
Some states subsequently authorized certain teachers and school employees to carry concealed firearms under specific training and approval requirements.
Supporters argue that armed staff members could potentially respond more quickly than outside law enforcement during a violent emergency.
They also maintain that the possibility of encountering armed resistance could discourage would-be attackers.
In 2018, the Federal Commission on School Safety recommended that districts seriously consider programs allowing qualified school personnel to receive firearms training and carry weapons.
However, the effectiveness and risks of those policies remain subjects of considerable disagreement.
Gun Control Organizations Dispute Claims That Armed Teachers Make Schools Safer
Organizations including Everytown for Gun Safety and GIFFORDS have consistently opposed expanding firearm access among teachers and school employees.
The groups argue that classroom educators generally do not receive the same tactical preparation as trained law enforcement officers and could face extraordinary challenges when responding to an armed attacker.
They also warn about accidental discharges, misplaced firearms and the possibility of students gaining access to improperly secured weapons.
Everytown's October 2025 research review concluded that available evidence did not demonstrate that arming teachers effectively deterred school shootings or reduced fatalities.
GIFFORDS has similarly argued that introducing additional firearms into schools creates safety risks that should not be overlooked.
Everytown Support Fund+1
The opposing conclusions demonstrate why school safety policies remain highly contested.
Lott's research emphasizes the relatively low number of reported attacks at schools permitting armed staff, while gun violence prevention organizations question whether those findings establish a protective effect.
School Shooting Deaths Increased During the Study Period
Beyond its findings on armed school personnel, the research identified an increase in annual shooting deaths on school property over the period examined.
In the earlier years, annual fatalities generally remained at or below approximately 12.
During the 2020s, however, the reported annual totals ranged from 18 to 51 deaths.
The study identified 2018 as its deadliest year, with 52 recorded fatalities.
The increase highlights the continuing challenge facing school administrators, lawmakers, parents and law enforcement agencies as they evaluate ways to prevent violence.
What the Findings Mean for America's School Safety Debate
The Crime Prevention Research Center's findings are likely to attract attention from legislators considering whether to authorize teachers and other school employees to carry concealed firearms.
Supporters of armed-staff policies view the reported absence of qualifying shooting casualties as evidence supporting their approach.
Opponents maintain that more rigorous research is needed to determine whether such policies actually prevent attacks or simply reflect differences between the schools adopting them.
The central statistical distinction is significant: a school policy allowing staff to carry firearms does not necessarily mean an armed employee was present during every school day.
Likewise, comparing the number of attacks across different categories of schools does not, by itself, establish that one security policy caused a lower rate of violence.
Further analysis of school enrollment, geographic differences, security policies and the actual presence of armed personnel would help evaluate the competing interpretations.
Nevertheless, the findings have introduced new data into a national discussion that continues to shape school safety policies.
With researchers reporting no qualifying shooting attack casualties at schools permitting authorized armed teachers over the 2000–2025 period, the study has renewed one of America's most consequential school security debates: whether armed educators provide an additional layer of protection or introduce risks that outweigh their potential benefits.
Source Attribution: The Washington Times, Crime Prevention Research Center, RealClearInvestigations, Everytown for Gun Safety and GIFFORDS.
